So, we made it into a Treasure Island party. Zack has a children's illustrated abridgment of the novel Treasure Island
We were out at garage sales (at Zack's request) when we noticed the boys playing around with a pile of something that looked like it would make a ship. I did a double-take, envisioning the centerpiece it could make. James was so shocked at my interest in a giant plastic toy that he almost fell down, but the boy selling it said he thought most of the parts were there so we piled it all in a box and left with it for the super bargain price of $7. James had to figure out hot to put it all together. Check how it turned out:
There is a Jolly Roger at the very top that doesn't show in the photo. It has maybe eight different sounds it makes, multiple trapdoors, cannons that flash and shoot little darts, a breakaway side, a lifeboat, a treasure chest, barrels and more. It's quite an impressive item (it appears to be the large ship from this set
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/39c89/39c89b1f08fe8bf93ff7de4e457eb92eca94e356" alt=""
Now, here's the problem: I put this text about looking for treasure on the invitation... so I was compelled to come up with some kind of treasure hunt! Aaack! I didn't know how to do a treasure hunt. I stressed and wrung my hands about it for the entire time between writing the invitations and the night before the party. I got great input from friends and family but I had this vague sense in my mind that I wanted it to follow the book and didn't know how to make that happen. I kept putting it off - preferring to stress and complain rather than do something I guess? - until the very last minute. James took the children on an errand and I told myself, "I must figure out the treasure hunt right now in case I need James to pick up anything." I sat down and wrote the whole thing in about an hour and came up with something we loved! Now why couldn't I have done that two weeks before and saved myself the anxiety??
The Treasure Hunt
If you would like to see how the treasure hunt was done, here you go.
The uncut piece of paper was a list of numbered instructions I read, one at a time. Each gave a bit of narrative and a hint where to find the corresponding clue. Each clue was a strip of paper that gave a little bit of the story.
We did them in order, revealing the basic (slightly nice-ified) plot of Treasure Island
The papers were all just printed on tan cardstock with the Stevenson Treasure Map in the background. I used the Blackadder ITC font for a cool pirate-y look, though even the readers couldn't always read the script lettering.
The treasure box was a hinged top shoe box (Nike) that I painted brown and added some horizontal black brushtrokes to make it wood-like. I painted a lock with gold - all cheap craft acrylics. We filled it with little mesh bags of chocolate gold coins, one for each kid, and glow bracelets. Pretty fun stuff.
Our final activity was dessert. Instead of cake we served Treasure Sundaes with ice cream, various syrups, crushed oreos and gingersnaps, peanuts, walnuts, m & ms, sprinkles, whip cream and cherries. Good times!